Valentine Bluffs

Mike Sutton

Sheriff John

Jeff Swisher

TJ Hanniger

Lloyd Kaufman

Mayor Thomas Otterman

Rachel Keefe

Kelly Hanniger

Christina Munn

Ginger

Roland Keller

Murphy

Joe Quick

Peter

Sarah Schoofs

Abby

Stevie Wilder

Little Peter

Chuck Ryan

The Miner / Axel Palmer

Michael Everett Johnson

The Priest

Richard John Walters

Paul

Laura Scott Wise

Sarah

Penny Nichols

Denise Hanniger

Kristy Adams

Lisa

Nicolai Kabana

Anthony Kabana

Shane Smith

Brent Edgett

Troy Oelke

Radio Caller (voice)

Bobby High

Creepy Radio Caller (voice)

J.J. Gonzalez

Jill Tainter (DJ) (voice)