Young Werther

Douglas Booth

Werther

Alison Pill

Charlotte

Patrick J. Adams

Albert

Iris Apatow

Sissy

Jaouhar Ben Ayed

Paul

Amrit Kaur

Melanie

Scott Thompson

Uncle Blochstein

Janelle Hutchison

Aunt Blochstein

Laurie Murdoch

Mr. Sandman

Liam Ma

Young Lawyer

Jaclyn Vogl

Sample Sale Employee

Michael Musi

Young Lawyer

John Thomas Gauthier

Doorman

Lisa Bunting

Board Head

Michael Giel

Gun Range Employee

Miles Carney

Worst Dancer Ever

Charlene McNabb

Mother

Alexis Harrison

Furious Server

Harriet Karsh

The Housekeeper

Jackson Jull

Freddy