Shelter Island

Ally Sheedy

Louise 'Lou' Delamere

Patsy Kensit

Alexandria 'Alex'

Stephen Baldwin

Lenny

Chris Penn

Sheriff Deluca

Mimi Langeland

Carly

Denia Brache

Agnes

Chris Douridas

Joel Shapiro

Joanna Glushak

Elyse Shapiro

Scott Sanford

Carly's Date

Joe Gironda

Dick Goldschmidt

Margaret Reed

Karen Goldschmidt

Timothy Devlin

Deputy Officer

Lou Ruggiero

Yelling Man

Jack Mulcahy

DJ Jack the Whack (voice)

Jennifer Alexander

Audience Member (uncredited)

Robert Z. Grant

Security Officer (uncredited)