Love with the Proper Stranger

Natalie Wood

Angie Rossini

Steve McQueen

Rocky Papasano

Edie Adams

Barbie

Herschel Bernardi

Dominick Rossini

Anne Hegira

Beetie

Harvey Lembeck

Julio Rossini

Mario Badolati

Elio Papasano

Penny Santon

Mama Rossini

Elena Karam

The Woman

Virginia Vincent

Anna

Nina Varela

Mrs. Columbo

E. Nick Alexander

Guido Rossini

Marilyn Chris

Gina

Augusta Ciolli

Mrs. Papasano

Wolfe Barzell

The Priest

Tom Bosley

Anthony Columbo

Richard Dysart

Accountant (uncredited)

Barney Martin

Sidney (uncredited)

Richard Mulligan

Louie (uncredited)

Vic Tayback

Cye (uncredited)