The Caller

Rachelle Lefevre

Mary Kee

Stephen Moyer

John Guidi

Luis Guzmán

George

Ed Quinn

Steven

Lorna Raver

Rose Lazar

Lydia Echevarría

Old Woman

Aris Mejias

Young Woman

Gladys Rodríguez

Concetta Guidi

Alfredo de Quesada

Attorney Davis

Brian Tester

Attorney Kirby

Grace Connelly

Dr. Hain

Cordelia González

Judge

Sunshine Logroño

John Guidi, Sr.

José E. Hernández

French Teacher

Sandra Rodríguez Rivera

Librarian

Jo Wyatt

Young Mary (voice)

Adriana Benitez

Young Mary (voice)

Luillo Ruiz

Mary's Landlord (voice)

David Rittenhouse

Real Estate agent (uncredited)

José Cotté

Social Services Clerk (uncredited)